Showing posts with label kevin gilbride. Show all posts
Showing posts with label kevin gilbride. Show all posts

Monday, December 19, 2011

SuperFan: Giants vs. Redskins (12/19/11)

You Can’t Be Serious

By Superfan

That was beyond appalling. While it probably isn’t true, from the stands it sure seemed like the players and coaches cared less about the outcome of our matchup with the Skins than the fans did. No sense of urgency, no sense of pride, no sense of the PLAYOFFS BEING ON THE LINE. There are some who will look at the bright side and think well, our backs are pressed as far against the wall as they’ll ever be, and that’s when we play our best, right? I suppose, but I expect better. We shouldn’t have to be the team who only plays well when no one expects us to, and when our season is riding on the outcome.

The View from the Meadowlands

I flew home for the holidays and therefore was able to go to the game on Sunday. With my buddy Jon in tow, we got there and parked around 12:30. With a CD playing “Proud to Be (a New York Giant)” on repeat, we pulled in amped as ever for the game to begin. It was imperative we beat Washington to keep pace with the Cowboys after their dismantling of the Bucs Saturday night. Jon had actually mentioned to me on Saturday that he felt this game might be tricky. Washington was a team who had nothing to lose, and was probably riding high after taking New England down to the wire the week before. True, but so what? This was a new Giants team, ready to shake off the stigma of playing down to the level of their competition. Ready to start beating the teams they’re supposed to beat, and looking like a legitimate contender in the process.

Unfortunately, it turned out Jon was onto something after all.

Things started off great in the seats. Good atmosphere, good vibes, no Redskins fans anywhere near us. The first play from scrimmage, Corey Webster made a great play to intercept a deep pass from Rex. Everyone was going nuts, sure Sunday would be a great day. Unfortunately, the next offensive series were three incomplete passes and a punt. Wasted opportunity, but still okay. A good punt pinned them at their own 30, but they drove down the field and settled for a field goal. Not great, but manageable. We only gave up three. Time for the offense to shine.

First play, seventeen-yard rush for Ahmad Bradshaw, followed by a decent four-yard gain. Then it happened. On 2nd and 6, Eli threw a perfect ball to a wide-open Jake Ballard that he dropped. Not only would it have been a first down, but maybe a huge-gainer as well. Then, on 3rd and 6, Eli went deep down the middle to Hakeem Nicks who had beaten the defense. It was a perfect ball that landed (for a moment) right in Nick’s outstretched arms, until he DROPPED IT! We were already celebrating the touchdown in the stands. No chance a number one receiver, with the playoffs on the line, could possibly drop such a perfect opportunity. But he did just that. Our defense got us the ball back right away though with a clutch interception by Kenny Phillips. When we got the ball back we got into a 3rd and 2 but thanks to a false start by Jake Ballard (what a day for him so far) we got pushed back to a 3rd and long and wound up having to punt the ball back again. Halfway through the first quarter, our offense had zero receptions while our defense had two. But after we punted back, the defense let up.

Jon and I switched seats many, many times throughout the game, to no avail. It was an ugly shocker, and made for a very quiet ride home. Yet again, with high hopes, I went to the stadium and was let down by the team I love so much. I’m sure the other 80,000 fans in attendance felt the same way.

A Disturbingly Familiar Sight

A bad team with nothing to play for comes to town against us, after we get a huge win to put us back on track, and we embarrass ourselves in front of the home crowd. This is getting ridiculous. Our defense is so bad it’s hard to watch. Seeing the secondary bicker with one another both on and off the field is like watching a Junior Varsity High School football team. Missed assignments, fingers being pointed at one another, zero accountability, a coordinator with no control over his players, and no shortage of undeserved trash talking (yes I’m talking to you, Antrel - until you start earning the obnoxious amount of money we’re paying you, keep your mouth shut). I started to feel that Coughlin should maybe start fining players for playing that badly. If you think about it, it’s like any profession. You get paid to perform. If a player isn’t earning his paycheck, either missing assignments or tackles, he should give some of it back. If a guy gets fined for being late to a meeting, why not fine him for leaving a receiver wide open? I also think that the defensive (and offensive, after Sunday) should be told not to talk to the media this week unless they’re apologizing. I know it seems extreme, but man I’m getting sick of this. Something should be done to wake these guys up.

Sunday was also some of the worst coordinating I’ve ever seen. Ahmad returned this week but only carried the ball ten times. Despite being down by twenty rather early in the 3rd quarter, we didn’t go to the no-huddle until the fourth. Our secondary gave their receivers huge cushions on every third and long. The middle of the field was once again completely open. Eli finally came back down to earth and threw three interceptions, two of them coming on pretty bad decisions. Can’t completely fault him though, because his star receiver kept him from having a great start to the game. Hard to play quarterback and have any confidence in your receivers when no one can make a clutch reception. On the interception he threw to the back corner, Mario should have turned around and caught the ball in front of the defender. Instead, he watched Josh Wilson go up and catch it before making a very feeble attempt at swatting it out of his hands. Coughlin made a horrible decision on his challenge in the first half. Bottom line, no one played well.

It’s a game worth forgetting. No game balls. Let’s just flush it.

Non-Gmen Thoughts of the Week:

· Had a doctor’s appointment on Monday morning. Saw some medical equipment that read, “delivered by Tony Gamboni.” You know you’re back in Jersey when the medical supplies are being delivered by a guy who sounds like a made-up character from a Sopranos parody.

· Nice win for KC, finally handing the Packers their first loss of the season. On the same day, the Colts got their first win of the season. Good for both cities and Romeo Crennel. Bad for Todd Haley and Tyler Palko. Needless to say I did very poorly in my picks this past weekend.

· Loved the Tim Tebow sketch on SNL this past weekend, but upset that it was the last sketch of the show. Means a lot of people probably missed it. Very, very funny.

· Saw Hugo, loved it. Still need to see MI: 4 and Sherlock Holmes 2 before this holiday is over. Still think The Muppets is the best film I’ve seen this year (so far).

Final Thoughts:

Crazy as it sounds, we still control our own destiny. Have two incredibly important games coming up against the Jets and Cowboys. We win them both, we win the division. Have to forget all about this loss and move forward. If we can get hot these last two weeks, we have a chance. I’m not giving up hope, and you shouldn’t either! Just ignore all sports media outlets this week (except giants.com, of course!) and you’ll be amazed how much less the loss stings. To talk all things Giants, e-mail me at gmensuperfan@gmail.com, find me on Facebook under the name “Gmen Superfan,” and follow me on Twitter under the name “@gmensuperfan1.” Have a great holiday weekend everyone, and until next week, GO GMEN!

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Superfan: Giants vs. Redskins (1/4/11)

Season Finale

By Superfan

Here we sit, seventeen grueling weeks of football in the books. Should we be upset and disappointed with the way the season turned out? Of course. Does the team need a complete re-shuffling? Well, those of us who know football well enough aren’t so dumb as to come to such a rash conclusion. Fortunately, John Mara is one of the smart ones, and made it a point to inform the public that Tom Coughlin’s job was safe. As it should be.

If you hadn’t seen any of the season play out, and simply heard the Giants finished the season 10-6 but missed the playoffs, most wouldn’t think that was incredibly unusual. Of course, if you watched any of the last three weeks, you’ve got a very different mindset. That was about as painful a way to end a season as any fan could imagine. Eight freakin’ minutes away from most likely the division crown and a first round bye even, and we’re now on the outside looking in, wishing we had something to cheer about for the rest of the month. But I’m getting ahead of myself. First let’s look back on our win over the Redskins.

Ending an Ugly Season with an Ugly Win

The team’s ultimate responsibility this past Sunday was to beat the Washington Redskins. While we had controlled our own destiny in previous weeks, we didn’t anymore. What was done was done, and all we could do was beat the Redskins and hope the Bears could beat the Packers. The Bears actually played their starters all game, something most thought wouldn’t happen. We took care of the Redskins in ugly fashion, but unfortunately the Bears couldn’t take care of Green Bay. Thus, we missed the playoffs, and the Pack snagged the final NFC wild card spot.

There was plenty to take away from the game itself, good and bad. Despite one legitimate drive at the end of the first half, our defense kept them in check most of the game. When a tipped pass turned into an interception, our defense came onto the field and got the ball right back when Osi stripped the ball from Rex Grossman’s hands before he could throw it. They did plenty of that all day, creating four turnovers.

Eli had a pretty good day, all things considered. The interception he threw was practically a hand-off from Mario Manningham to Philip Buchanan. Hagan dropped what would’ve been a touchdown pass in the middle of the first quarter. It was pretty obvious that Eli was playing with a bunch of back-ups, although his balls have been sailing a bit this season on normally open routes. Maybe there’s miscommunication on what routes are being run, or maybe Eli’s flat out missing receivers. Only the coaches and players really know. Boss made a great catch near the end of the second quarter to set up Brandon Jacob’s touchdown run, but as fans we shouldn’t be praying he hangs on every time the ball is thrown his way. I wouldn’t be surprised to see an open competition for the position this offseason between Boss, Beckum, and Bear Pascoe. I also wouldn’t be surprised to see the Giants go after a free agent or draft someone in April. I’m not saying they will, I’m just saying I wouldn’t be surprised if they did.

The best way to see the kind of toll being taken on a patchwork offensive line is by the success or failure of the rushing game. Jacobs and Bradshaw did well in the first half, but there were no lanes for them after halftime. Not to say Boothe didn’t do a great job filling in for Seubert when he went down, but an offensive line as beat up as ours, taking further toll in the last week of the regular season, can only hold on for so long. I’d say the guys in there did a great job considering.

Now, let’s delve into the bad. I don’t believe that Eli’s intentionally taking a long time in the huddle before approaching the line. I have to think the plays are getting in late, because once again, now in the LAST WEEK OF THE REGULAR SEASON, we had to waste a timeout due to an expiring play clock. Week 17. You can’t be serious. Speaking of play calling: down 10-7, twenty-two seconds left in the first half (remember, we kick off to start the second half), ball near midfield. Three timeouts. AND WE RUN THE BALL? Sorry Coach Gilbride, but an offense can’t do much when you don’t let them try. Second possession of the game, and we have a great drive going. After Derek Hagan dropped a would-be touchdown pass on 2nd down, Gilbride calls a draw play on 3rd and goal from the six. Can you sense a pattern forming? This team has shown potential to be a great big play offense many times in the past. Yet they continue to struggle in the clutch year after year. I have to think a more competent coordinator could do wonders with our talent, even with our two star receivers out.

Special teams were awful. They have been all season. Punt team, kickoff coverage, the field goal unit, all of it. It’s no secret some big changes need to be made there in the offseason.

So that was the game in a nutshell. Congrats to Eli and Mario, whose 92-yard touchdown hookup was the third-longest touchdown pass in franchise history.

Coughlin’s a Great Coach, and Deserves to Be Here Next Season

The players love him and want to play for him. The front office knows he’s the guy. Giants’ fans that know football and pay attention to the games want him back. The only people who don’t want him back are rash sportswriters and “fans” who don’t think before they speak, or type.

This team played with a patchwork offensive line all season, and was without two of our star wideouts most of the year. Our stud return man went on IR before the season started, and even the depth of our receiving corps got hit when Barden went on IR. We finished the season with TEN WINS. And everyone wants him gone? Are you even paying attention?

As for the Cowher argument, I have several points to make. First of all, he never gave anyone a “list” of teams he wanted to coach for next season. He probably said, in passing, “Oh, the Giants would be a fun challenge.” But everyone who knows him says he’s pretty happy in his current role at CBS. Everything else is hearsay, nothing more than New York media hype created out of lack of substance. Also, I personally don’t believe Bill Cowher would be a significant step up from Tom Coughlin. They’re both disciplinarians, with very similar coaching styles. They each have one Super Bowl ring. Cowher went to the big dance twice – got blown out the first time, and barely hung on to beat a far lesser opponent in the “lucky-to-be-there” Seattle Seahawks back in Super Bowl XL. Tom Coughlin’s been there once, when the Road Warrior Gmen faced the then-undefeated New England Patriots, and he won. Say what you will about comparative overall playoff records. Where it matters most, Tom Coughlin’s got a 100% success rate, while Cowher’s is 50%. I’m just saying. The team and the players believe in Tom Coughlin. Why should we have to convince the fans to believe in him, too? Makes no sense to me.

Non-Gmen Thoughts of the Week:

· Great line from the Fox commentators after Suebert went down – “How do they respond emotionally to this, with all their emotions?” That’s Ivy League material right there.

· Speaking of Fox coverage, despite my overall hatred for it, did everyone else love what Fox did with the robot graphic? The day after National Hangover Day (more popularly known as “New Year’s”), the robot’s sitting down with an ice pack on his forehead. Awesome.

· The Winter Classic has to be one of the greatest new events to happen to sports in a long time. It’s just awesome to see hockey outdoors on such a grand stage. HBO’s 24/7 series is amazing as well, making the game itself that much more enjoyable.

· Saw Black Swan and True Grit over the holiday break. Both were incredible films, for very different reasons. Might want to warn those who are feint of heart though before seeing Black Swan – to say it’s intense would be the understatement of the New Year.

· Goodell – the fans don’t want a letter. We want you to come to your senses. Please. Thank you.

Until Next Season

We ended last season 8-8, and missed the playoffs by a lot. This season we were 10-6, and just missed the playoffs. We had two weeks to control our own fate, and couldn’t seal the deal. Instead of looking for people to blame, which it seems is what the New York sports media does better than anyone, let’s look to where we can build for next season. We’ve got some work to do, but I trust the guys in our front office to get it done. It’s going to be a long, hard offseason. It’s not going to be easy. But I’m still going to stay true blue, and I know you all will too. Remember, it only hurts this much because we care so much about the Gmen. I’d love to continue chatting with you fans during the offseason, either via e-mail at gmensuperfan@gmail.com, or on Facebook under the name “Gmen Superfan.” Happy New Year, and until next season, GO GMEN!

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

SuperFan: Giants vs. Cowboys (9/22/09)

Nice Pick, Jerry

By Superfan

Wow. I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: there should be an antibiotic for being a New York Giants fan. Still, you gotta love being a fan of this team. To go into Dallas, as they opened a new stadium which, according to NBC’s lead-in (probably at the request of Jerry Jones), was comparable to the Taj Majal, and WIN – doesn’t get much better than that in Week 2. I think they should get a snapshot of Jerry Jones’s expression at the end of that game, place it alongside a picture of him on the sidelines after we beat them in the divisional championship a couple years ago, frame them, and hang them somewhere in the new stadium when it opens next season (oh, I almost forgot to include the picture of him ring-deep in his nose after we made a pick of our own). Because I just love seeing his face after we beat them. He must hate the Gmen so much, and few things could make this Giants fan happier.

And what a crazy game it was! This team continues to prove people wrong week in and week out. Going into this game, there were several reasons why we wouldn’t win. “Our secondary was beaten up and too slow for Cowboy receivers.” They picked Romo off three times, with one getting run back for a TD (shoulda been two, but I’ll get to that later). “The receivers were unproven and too young to perform well enough in the spotlight.” Really? Two receiving touchdowns and nearly three hundred yards receiving between Steve Smith and Mario Manningham beg to differ. “The Cowboys defensive line were all over Eli last season, recording 12 sacks in the two match-ups.” And? They hardly laid a finger on the guy all game. Once again, the best offensive line in football showed everyone why they deserve that title.
As a character study in just falling short of being elite, Eli Manning might take the cake. I can’t understand it. For half of the game, you hate the guy, and the other half you love him. He’ll make a great play to get out of a sack, scrambling out of the pocket beautifully, only to miss a wide open receiver by twenty feet. But there’s no one I’d rather have behind center to lead a comeback drive in the fourth quarter. If he could only get over that little hump of inconsistency that’s plagued him his entire career, there’s no question he’d be one of the top three or four in the league. He’ll seem to show these flashes of brilliance at times on the field that make you wonder how someone with so much natural ability, intelligence, and toughness can, at times, make your insides churn. Maybe he’s past all that, and what we’re seeing are early-season jitters, simple timing mistakes that will take care of themselves as he spends more time with these young receivers on the field throughout the season. One thing’s for sure – he’s led us to two big divisional wins, with a pretty nice QB rating of 103.2 to show for it.
It’s funny how proud I was of our defense, despite giving up thirty-one points. Although they gave up that field goal just before the end of the first half, and let Dallas run all over them in the second half, they were still able to overcome the 105,000+ fan-fueled homefield advantage Dallas had going for them and successfully got in Romo’s head. Even though they didn’t sack him, they knocked him down quite a bit, and picked him off three times. And they did this even though it sure looked like the referees were doing everything in their power to not throw any flags on the Cowboys. It was almost as bad as those Big Ten referees that call the games in Notre Dame when a team from said conference come into town to play them. The first holding penalty called against Dallas didn’t happen until the 3rd quarter, and it was on their defense. Come on. And what Flozell Adams did to Justin Tuck was inexcusable. He shoulda been tossed from the game. The guy’s been playing like this his whole career, and all he gets for it each time is a little tripping penalty. If you get beat on a play, be a man and deal with it, but don’t cheat. Guys get hurt from cheap plays like that. Props to Justin Tuck for being the bigger man and not retaliating. It doesn’t hurt to show those other guys what true class is all about.
And how about these young receivers of ours! Steve Smith and Mario Manningham have done an excellent job stepping up in the clutch, and you can see the trust that’s developed between them and Eli. When Eli throws their way, he knows they have the playmaking abilities to catch the ball and do something with it. If only our game-plan could include Kevin Boss a little more, especially in the red zone, then we’d really be dominant passing team.
Lastly, I can’t forget to mention Lawrence Tynes, who always manages to step up and redeem himself when we need him most. Way to show up Wade’s ridiculous freeze attempt by striking it clean through the second time around.

Despite all the greatness that comes from such a huge win on the road against a division rival, there is room for cynicism (or as they say in the post game interviews – “improvement”). Once again, I’m going to have to repeat myself: if we continue to play scared in the red zone, we’ll never become a great team. Just like last week, when the team was driving early and getting the ball well into scoring position, we refused to throw the ball into the end zone, and had to settle for field goals. Which meant that for the second straight week, we barely scraped out a victory which in fact should have been a blowout. Coach Gilbride – you have to at least give the offense a chance to make something happen in the red zone.

This game was especially enjoyable to watch for me because I was back home in Jersey. All the old familiar faces came, and it was like a G-Men viewing reunion. My dad, my brother, my buddy Jon, and a few family friends were all over to watch it. Just like old times, the house was rocking Sunday night, and the nostalgia made for a great combination of joy and indigestion.
The game was made even better by the comments I received during the game from those of you I’ve now friended on facebook. I obviously can’t repeat any of the comments here, but they were quite hilarious and entertaining. If you haven’t yet, feel free to look me up under “Gmen Superfan.” Also, I love hearing from you via e-mail at gmensuperfan@gmail.com, so keep those coming.
While there is still room for improvement, as a Giants fan, you should be feeling pretty good. Can’t wait to invade Tampa Bay next Sunday! Until next week, GO G-MEN!!!!

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

SuperFan: Giants vs. Eagles (1/13/09)

Wait a Second, That’s Not the Ending I Read in the Script….

By SuperFan 

DISCLAIMER:  The following is a rant.  Pure and simple.  It is entirely fan-fueled, and the opinions expressed herein are derived entirely from the passion and emotion of being a New York Giants fan. Some of it was written shortly after the loss occurred (hence the extreme agitation), and the rest a day or so later, after I’d let the whole situation really sink in.  All that being said, it’s still a rant.  Given what took place last Sunday, you should understand why it might sound mean and extremely agitated.  Hey, what kind of fan would a person be if they didn’t care enough to get upset about their team?  Okay – you’ve been warned.  Enjoy!

 

            This isn’t fair.  AT ALL.  Everything that was great and magical about this whole season, from the day after we won the Super Bowl last February until now, was practically undone Sunday afternoon.  I realize that football is a team sport, but in my opinion, most of the blame for the abomination that took place at Giants Stadium on January 11th falls on the shoulders of one person, and it’s NOT Eli Manning (although I’ve got a bone to pick with him as well).  No, I’m blaming Kevin Gilbride for this one.  Or should I say Kevin KILL-DRIVE! 

            This guy’s supposed to be one of the top candidates for a head coaching position next season?!?!  REALLY?!?!  That was the worst play-calling I’ve ever seen in my entire life.  It’s like he never looked at a single piece of film during the whole two weeks we had off!  Here are a few examples to support my argument:

            We start the game off with the ball, with great starting field position thanks to an incredible kick return by Ahmad Bradshaw, going into the wind.  The first play we called would have been a good call if we had the wind at our backs.  But to try a deep ball right off the back throwing towards the windiest corner of the stadium?  Yeah - that’ll get a quarterback’s confidence started on the right track.  Later, after the Eagles drove scored easily following an ugly pick that they ran back to our 2-yard line, making the score 7-3, when we really needed a big offensive drive to gain the momentum back, Jacobs doesn’t even get on the field!

            When the fourth-and-one occurred in the second half, and we (questionably at best) decided to go for it, what play did we call?  We let Eli try to take it himself against an Eagles defensive front that had been playing ferociously all game, while Brandon Jacobs stood by helplessly in the backfield!  Then, when we faced a critical fourth-and-two (not one, not inches – TWO), we tried to let Jacobs pound it in on a draw.  A draw?!  How can a big man be expected to build enough momentum for a quick, short gain with the entire defense blitzing using a draw play?  It makes less sense than a sixty-something-year-old Indiana Jones surviving a nuclear explosion by hiding in a refrigerator!  On that same drive (I think), when we FINALLY starting going to the no-huddle with six-and-change left in the fourth quarter (we should have started using it much earlier), we ran all running plays!  We had finally gotten some momentum going with the offense, when we really needed it, and Eli didn’t even get a shot to do anything with the ball.  Then we finished that drive with the ugly fourth-and-two draw play.  Embarrassing.

           

            But it wasn’t all the play-calling.  The offense is supposed to execute the plays that are called, and we really didn’t.  Eli was throwing passes to the receivers that looked like balls he’d normally only throw to Plaxico.  Once again, we had to waste a timeout early in the second half because of bad clock management.  Critical penalties on both sides of the ball killed us in the field position battle. 

 

            The worst part of all (of course) was that it happened against the Eagles.  THE EAGLES!  AT HOME!  How did that happen?  I’ve been saying it all season, and it hasn’t entirely been for my own re-affirmation – I truly believed we were meant to repeat this year.  In all my heart, deep in my gut, I really believed it.  And it all got shot down against the one team we hate the most.  Plus, now everyone will feel almost vindicated about calling them “this year’s Giants.” 

            What does this mean?  Is it really the hip new trend now to be on the road during the post-season.  What would have happened if we’d lost that game against the Panthers in week 16?  Would we have been better off?  Are we not supposed to play extra-hard during the regular season to try and earn the top seed in the playoffs?  Are bye weeks more risk than reward?  SOMEBODY PLEASE MAKE SENSE OF THINGS!!!!

            One thing’s for certain – no matter what off the field issues may have happened, or what I may have said in the past – we really could have used Plaxico on the field Sunday.  Or the past 6-7 weeks, for that matter.  Now I’m hearing nearly all the players on the team are saying they want him to play next season.  You know what – me too!  Hey, we let it slide with LT, and it worked out for us – why not turn a blind eye once more? 

            I’m sorry – that was terrible.  I shouldn’t have said that.  I didn’t really mean it.  You see what this chaos has done to me?  It’s tearing me apart!!

           

            Well, all these questions and more will have to wait until next season to be answered.  It was a truly horrible end to the season, but in retrospect, it was a great season.  Let’s not get all George Steinbrenner on the Gmen and disregard every positive that took place during the year just because we didn’t win the whole thing.  The 2007 Giants’ were a magical team with a “perfect” finish, so of course it hurts a lot now that they’ve failed to repeat.  I don’t want football season to be over, the players and coaches don’t want the season to be over, and I KNOW you fans don’t want the season to be over.  But, it is. 

            Coach Spags, I can only pray that you’ll be back again next year.  If not, I wish you all the best wherever you end up.  It’s been a privilege having you as our defensive coordinator the last two seasons. 

            I’ve had a great time writing this season, and have especially enjoyed hearing from all of you every week.  To all the fans I visited with before the game on Sunday, thanks for hospitality, and thanks for your spirit.  The only way this team can fully recover from this is by the continued support and enthusiasm of its incredible fan base.  If anyone’s been known to bounce back from far worse conditions, it’s the New York Football Giants!  I would love to keep up with you guys during the off-season, so please keep in touch!  Once again, the address is gmensuperfan@gmail.com.  Thanks for a fantastic year, and until next season, GO GMEN!!